Episode 32 - GoF Chapter 16: The Tallest Filing Cabinet of Harry Potter

Episode 32 – GoF Chapter 16: The Tallest Filing Cabinet of Harry Potter

Join hosts Aureo, Irvin, Sam, and guest Natalie Candido as they discuss the titular chapter full of teenage gossip and French food in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.

In this episode:

  • How rude can we be to international students?
  • The fire that’s filled with goblets
  • Very fond hedge memories
  • This tournament needed more planning
  • Dumbledore speaks Hedge
  • Fanfiction is everywhere
  • Irvin will forever be right
  • Who should have judged the tournament?
  • How hard to find was Karkaroff’s shack?
  • The Goblet of Fire’s second career in reality television
  • How does the aging potion work?

Pub’s Jukebox:

Durmstrang Boy by The Parselmouths

Posted in Aureo, Chapters, Episodes, Goblet of Fire, Irvin, Sam.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
9 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
AbsentMindedRavenD
AbsentMindedRaven
23 days ago
  • I like the concept of Ron as jumping on the Krum bandwagon. It adds a little something to his calling out Cho for being on the Tornadoes bandwagon.
  • If the staff are so big on sitting together at meals as a way to foster understanding and develop friendships and all that, why do they have separate house tables in the first place?
  • Haggis fingies exist – most people would call them sausages.
  • Harry’s observations are very good at identifying threats (anything else, not so much). He doesn’t really understand other genders or sexualities, so while he sees some girls swooning over Fleur, he doesn’t interpret it as that.
Irvin
Irvin
Editor
Reply to  AbsentMindedRaven
21 days ago

why do they have separate house tables in the first place?

They’re big on fostering international friendships, not inter-house ones! Some things are just too big a stretch 😉

AbsentMindedRavenD
AbsentMindedRaven
20 days ago
  • If Hogwarts has a resident hedge-witch, I don’t think Dumbledore fits the bill (he’s more of a hedgefund-witch).
  • A useful marking-scheme I’ve seen (that could be applied to the tasks) is based on the idea of Achieved/Merit/Excellence. The first two can have set standards/criteria, and then the third is “impress me”.
  • An obvious hack for the lake-task springs to mind: could you successfully bribe the merfolk to report about how amazing you were (e.g. refusing to leave until all the hostages were rescued), and how bad the others were?
Irvin
Irvin
Editor
Reply to  AbsentMindedRaven
19 days ago

What do you think the merfolk would want as bribes?

AbsentMindedRavenD
AbsentMindedRaven
Reply to  Irvin
18 days ago

I imagine you could get their attention if you offered gadgets and gizmos a-plenty. Maybe add whozits and whatzits galore. And a dinglehopper.

Irvin
Irvin
Editor
Reply to  AbsentMindedRaven
18 days ago

Good point! I’m just fairly sure thingamabobs wouldn’t work, they’ve already got twenty.

AbsentMindedRavenD
AbsentMindedRaven
Reply to  Irvin
17 days ago

Or, you know, feet. Quentin Tarantuna is a sad little merlad.

I’d say anything Shi-ney, but they’re not crabs.

AbsentMindedRavenD
AbsentMindedRaven
16 days ago

Besides their biases cancelling each other out, there’s another reason having the three Heads as judges of the tournament makes sense: they know (or should know) exactly what is taught at their school, so can recognise when their school’s champion has gone above-and-beyond.

It’s the difference between “Ooo, a bubble-head charm! We don’t cover that!” versus “Meh, we teach them bubble-head charms in sixth-year.”

So, what I’m hearing is that the Goblet of Fire’s modus operandi is to choose a group with a heaping helping of sexual chemistry and whom it would be hilarious to watch try to keep their hands to themselves?

I wonder if the issue with ageing/de-ageing potions is the quantity you’d need to drink to have a significant effect. Fred and George only need a couple of drops (for roughly 5 months), but maybe the dose required doubles for each additional month.

I wonder if Karkaroff was used as a test for getting the taboo going again. The Death Eaters found him by sending him an owl with the message “Say ‘Voldemort’ “.

Irvin
Irvin
Editor
Reply to  AbsentMindedRaven
16 days ago

So, what I’m hearing is that the Goblet of Fire’s modus operandi is to choose a group with a heaping helping of sexual chemistry and whom it would be hilarious to watch try to keep their hands to themselves?

Well, YEAH! If you’re a magical artefact that only exists to ensure a thrilling and successful Triwizard Tournament… romantic entanglements are a must to put on a good show!

Maybe the goblet didn’t even need all that much convincing to include Harry in the tournament. “Oh, he has a romantic connection with the girlfriend of one champion, and is best friends with the object of another’s affection? Sold! Let’s make some draaaamaaaaa!”